Who is the greatest Musician of all time?

[[Koolaid]]

Mike Portnoy.

Youngest drummer in the drummer hall of fame.

 

[N[U]TS]

Mike Portnoy.

Youngest drummer in the drummer hall of fame.

I looked him up on youtube and watched him play a neil peart drum solo. pretty damn good.

 

[Tw@]

Britney Spears
Christina Aguilera
The Spice Girls

-Frank

Look guys, we have on our hands a real ****in comedian

 

[RyanXWing]

David Gilmour

 

[Jimbo]

man **** you guys

i love lennon =[

 

[Carbon]

Avril Levigne. That chick fuckin rips shit up.

 

[AZN_FLEA]

Britney Spears
Christina Aguilera
The Spice Girls

-Frank

this is coming from the idiot who likes kurt cobain. your opinion doesnt matter. kurt was a shit musician.

Didnt care for his music -- much less his politics. Beatles were much better.

shoot I loved while my guitar gently weeps by george harrison.


ill name another oldie some of you may have heard of them. If not check them out if you like the beatles.
simon and garfunkel the sound of silence is an amazing song

one or two songs dont make a good musician. simon and garfunkel was good but you have to realise that there are many other good musicans that are vastly superior.

man **** you guys

i love lennon =[

another retard right here. lennons technique sucks too much.

Avril Levigne. That chick muffinin rips shit up.

suicide right now.

 

[Jimbo]

this is coming from the idiot who likes kurt cobain. your opinion doesnt matter. kurt was a shit musician.





one or two songs dont make a good musician. simon and garfunkel was good but you have to realise that there are many other good musicans that are vastly superior.



another retard right here. lennons technique sucks too much.



suicide right now.

Lol. Lennon was one of the greatest song writers... Since when has that had to do with technique?

 

[Arkillo]

Tech N9ne nigga.

 

[[[[Rextasy]]]]

Ray Charles

 

[AZN_FLEA]

Lol. Lennon was one of the greatest song writers... Since when has that had to do with technique?

songwriting isnt ALL there is to a musician.

 

[Teddy]

bob dylan

hands down.

 

[Jimbo]

songwriting isnt ALL there is to a musician.

Neither is technique.

 

[AZN_FLEA]

Neither is technique.

did i in anyway imply that because i dont think i did.

my opinion still stands. chuck schuldiner is the best. and no jim, he isnt another yngwie malmsteen

 

[Carbon]

did i in anyway imply that because i dont think i did.

my opinion still stands. chuck schuldiner is the best. and no jim, he isnt another yngwie malmsteen

John Lennon was revolutionary. I can't even name one piece of music Chuck Schuldiner wrote, and I know alot more about music then you. :brag:

 

[AZN_FLEA]

chuck is better than james hetfield and kirk put together yet hes still not as famous because metallica played ear friendly songs. popularity isnt a deciding factor in making a musician. i dont know every metal band there is but most of them are better than mainstream shit. just cuz you cant name it, it doesnt make it shit. john lennon made exrtemely earfriendly songs, its obvious he would be acknowledged more.

but yeah i acknowledge john lennon. i just dont think that songwriting alone is enough to put you up at the top. heck jimi hendrix revolutionised guitar playing but hes not up there is he?

 

[Carbon]

Popularity is something that people gain with creating good music. Good music in the sense that people like it.

 

[AxL]

There is no such thing as the "greatest musician".

 

[AZN_FLEA]

Popularity is something that people gain with creating good music. Good music in the sense that people like it.

that is sometimes true. mostly not. people like pop but all pop is is a good looking figure head + music producer.

seriously, popularity doesnt mean shit.

on the other hand, i can give the best musician place to john lennon. secod place can be chuck