Retirement Clarification

[Zeroth]

ok, i am NOT making maps, i'm just a map critic. if didn't know, am going to be VERY critical, though. i'll point out flaws in the map first, then say whats good. bad news first is good a lot... sometimes, if its really bad, i won't follow that format. good first, then bad...

 

[Alton]

If ypu want us to reply to somthing, ask us a question or type somthing we can understand!

 

[Magikarp]

Originally posted by Lord Hishado
ok, i am NOT making maps, i'm just a map critic. if didn't know, am going to be VERY critical, though. i'll point out flaws in the map first, then say whats good. bad news first is good a lot... sometimes, if its really bad, i won't follow that format. good first, then bad...

A self proclaimed critic? How quaint..

If you want to review maps, then make a website. Also, do you have any experience at reviewing?

 

[Bolt Head]

I have a map reveiws thread on Staredit.net, feel free to add reviews there. Just follow the format and all.

http://www.staredit.net/?showtopic=1727

 

[Renzokuken]

Is there a certain structure you have to follow to review maps properly?

 

[Bolt Head]

What you need to know is in the second post. Just a format you have to follow. Just come up with a score out of 10 and tell what you think about it and why you choice that score. There isn't any "structure" If you don't belive terrain or overlap is important then I wouldn't make your rate people on it.